#034: Disrupting Fields: How to Build Frameworks for Analyzing Power Dynamics

The Criterion Institute Podcast

In this episode, Joy discusses the Criterion Institute's paper "Disrupting Fields", and the power dynamics that shape the development of ecosystems and fields of thought. She firstly introduces the idea of a 'thinking all the thoughts' document as a way to explore ideas and create frameworks when writing a paper of this kind.

Joy then explores the paper in more detail, including the six categories of power dynamics in field building: cultural norms determining value, leaders signalling authority, experts naming what knowledge matters, connections that define inclusion, structures that solidify control, and resources reinforcing privilege. She emphasizes the importance of understanding and addressing these power dynamics in order to create transformative change.

Episode Highlights

• 00:27 - Introduction and Background
• 03:22 - The Practice of 'Thinking All the Thoughts'
• 10:18 - Disrupting Fields: Understanding Power Dynamics
• 12:46 - Cultural Norms and Value in Field Building
• 15:38 - Leadership and Authority in Field Building
• 18:04 - Experts and the Power to Define Knowledge
• 21:00 - Creating Inclusive Connections in Field Building
• 22:53 - Structures: Solidifying or Challenging Power Dynamics
• 25:16 - Resources and Privilege in Field Building

Relevant Links

• Criterion Institute website and LinkedIn
• Joy’s LinkedIn